Handful of Nothing

By Krisse:

You see Canola as over-simplified, but I see Hildon as over-complicated. I think the reason we disagree is because we have totally different ideas about the kind of person that would be a potential tablet user.

I would just change that to not use the actual things, but what they represent : Canola would be replaced by a task / simplified user experience to the Hildon as “desktop-like more featured experience”.

Sorry for the prolific post before :/ Thanks Krisse, to point out everything in 2 lines.

Apart from the title, that is just to grab your attention I really wanted to make sure some people understand one thing: Knowing how to criticize is a crucial thing to have your message heard. Also I wanted Maemo Developers and some heavy users to know another thing: The most important thing your software or your device must have is a target group, the group to which you design and develop your user interfaces.

So, the guys over tabletschool, were very kind with our project, but What I want to talk is on the end :

There’s been a lot of rather strong feedback (EXTREMELY strong, some of it!) for this article already, which is the main reason the ITS has avoided editorials. :-)

This would make me sad, if I was not surrounded by great Developers (physically or in the net - IRC, Gtalk) that are concerned with more than their own belly button. Let me clarify some thing that may help you understand better what is “User Centered Design”:

We picked a user profile. We analyze their needs, We see the competitors, We try to solve the USERs problem and most important: we try to solve that “User” profile problems, not EVERYONE’s problem. Why? Because it’s simply impossible to do so.

With that said, I then ask all the thumbs down guy here on maemo planet to read the following sentence:

“If you don’t agree with the basic concept behind canola, the simplicity and focus on consuming not editing, then Canola is not for you.”

But hei! What is the beauty of open platforms? : You have choice. You have the Hildon UI, you have KDE so you’re actually more well served than those users that do not care for the 95% of features you miss in Canola or any other simplified UI. They care about User oriented interfaces, not a powerhouse interface, and I can be wrong with that but the massive amount of emails I receive gives me the hint that there are a lot of user who wants the simplicity way.

Don’t get me wrong, this is like Itschools not about technical matters. I’m the one here in the company who says: I don’t care what Acronym you’re going to use, I just want the best user experience with everything that we can do on it. I want the cherry on top of the user’s pie. If you don’t think it’s important, pass it forward there are a lot of people that do care about.

And just to make clear: ~80% of the email asked for features, complained about bugs, requested improvements but none asked to include regular UI elements on the software. Why? They understood the goal.

So please, stop felling “hurt” when people talks good things about things you don’t agree. I think Hildon is a desktop like UI, and thus provide a desktop like experience. Canola tried to fill the other gap. If users think they should have more Canola, it’s their rights, as much as you think Hildon should “be ok for them”. It’s not. That’s why the use Canola (or the other apps) and that’s why We focus on python development. Because we believe we need to do more, in a simple and python give us that power.

And about the whole Canola thing: If you also really want to criticize, I know it takes time, but read the forums in ITT. Look at our way of dealing with users. We do treat them as co-developers. We do listen, we do change. But we stick to our goal.

Also to make clear another thing, this time for the tabletschool: http://tableteer.nokia.com/tableteer/os2008/team_marcelo.xhtml, INdT stands for : Nokia Technology Institute and Canola only exists because Nokia indeed wanted it to exist. As I said Canola is in opposite direction to Hildon, but that doesn’t mean Hildon is not good. It just means that the user focus is different.

Concluding: Please understand the concept of user centered design, before trying to compare things. And please be ok with the fact that it was not made for you. As it probably was not made for the one who made it. Or do you really thing all the Devs in the team were happy to hear me shout that the thing was not “smooth” and fluffly enough?

There’s a LOT MORE after the click :) But please, bare in mind that the topic here is not about Canola, or hildon or this or even your taste. It’s about being humble enough to figure out that sometimes you may not be the target.

Continue reading…

You were arrested in a foreign country by “no reason”… What do you do? you twitter “Arrested” then all your friends will call your embassy on the country you are to set you free faster than a bullet.

http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/04/16/twitter-saves-man-from-egyptian-justice/

I can’t imagine a better publicity for twitter than this :)

Ad ons video
Also, from my friend Marco Gomes the “impressive” demo from videoclix : here. Ok, are we coming back to hand (manual) indexing?

And last but not least:
I will do some publicity myself : http://www.hulu.com/ , While I do like the amateurish videos from youtube, or even the “to hell with ip” content I must admit : hulu.com looks just sweet. Oh god, I like clean designs :)

The post entitled Visualizing Fitt’s law is really a nice reading. Even if you have read that more than 5 times before, you will like the way it was written and illustrated. A nice bookmark for those who are “consulted” a lot in the Ux field :)

For those who are starting, and wanted more, maybe “real world” view of it : What about MS office ? and last but not least the graphical view at Mind Hack.

And in those links you will be able to find some small pearls, also worth bookmarking :
here (on Hick’s law, here on Gom and also this on the Power law of practice

This :

The 37signals’s post tells exactly what I was prepared to post. I just feel sorry for the probably competent Interaction designer who was the one to carrier the “I Don’t care! I want just like the IPHONE” task.

We are trying to hit beta10 :) this release adds the requested audioscrobbling and fixes a lot of previous problems. If you use Canola2 please make sure to update, update themes and then install Last.fm and youtube updated version.

Hope people like it :)

Changelog : http://www.openbossa.indt.org/canola/news.html

Developer tool : http://www.openbossa.indt.org/canola/developer.html